Initial commit: Brachnha Insight project setup

- Next.js 14+ with App Router and TypeScript - Tailwind CSS and ShadCN UI styling - Zustand state management - Dexie.js for IndexedDB (local-first data) - Auth.js v5 for authentication - BMAD framework integration Co-Authored-By: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-01-26 12:28:43 +07:00
commit 3fbbb1a93b
812 changed files with 150531 additions and 0 deletions
--- a/_bmad/bmb/workflows/agent/data/agent-compilation.md
+++ b/_bmad/bmb/workflows/agent/data/agent-compilation.md
@@ -0,0 +1,273 @@
+# Agent Compilation: YAML Source → Final Agent
+
+> **For the LLM running this workflow:** This document explains what the compiler adds. When building agents, focus on the YAML structure defined here—do NOT add things the compiler handles automatically.
+>
+> **Example reference:** Compare `{workflow_path}/data/reference/module-examples/architect.agent.yaml` (source, 32 lines) with `architect.md` (compiled, 69 lines) to see what the compiler adds.
+
+---
+
+## Quick Overview
+
+You write: **YAML source file** (`agent-name.agent.yaml`)
+Compiler produces: **Markdown with XML** (`agent-name.md`) for LLM consumption
+
+The compiler transforms your clean YAML into a fully functional agent by adding:
+- Frontmatter (name, description)
+- XML activation block with numbered steps
+- Menu handlers (workflow, exec, action)
+- Auto-injected menu items (MH, CH, PM, DA)
+- Rules section
+
+---
+
+## What YOU Provide (YAML Source)
+
+Your YAML contains ONLY these sections:
+
+```yaml
+agent:
+  metadata:
+    id: "_bmad/..."
+    name: "Persona Name"
+    title: "Agent Title"
+    icon: "🔧"
+    module: "stand-alone" or "bmm" or "cis" or "bmgd"
+
+  persona:
+    role: "First-person role description"
+    identity: "Background and specializations"
+    communication_style: "How the agent speaks"
+    principles:
+      - "Core belief or methodology"
+
+  critical_actions:              # Optional - for Expert agents only
+    - "Load ./sidecar/memories.md"
+    - "Load ./sidecar/instructions.md"
+    - "ONLY access ./sidecar/"
+
+  prompts:                        # Optional - for Simple/Expert agents
+    - id: prompt-name
+      content: |
+        <instructions>Prompt content</instructions>
+
+  menu:                           # Your custom items only
+    - trigger: XX or fuzzy match on command-name
+      workflow: "path/to/workflow.yaml"   # OR
+      exec: "path/to/file.md"             # OR
+      action: "#prompt-id"
+      description: "[XX] Command description"
+```
+
+---
+
+## What COMPILER Adds (DO NOT Include)
+
+### 1. Frontmatter
+```markdown
+---
+name: "architect"
+description: "Architect"
+---
+```
+**DO NOT add** frontmatter to your YAML.
+
+### 2. XML Activation Block
+```xml
+<activation critical="MANDATORY">
+  <step n="1">Load persona from this current agent file</step>
+  <step n="2">Load config to get {user_name}, {communication_language}</step>
+  <step n="3">Remember: user's name is {user_name}</step>
+  <!-- YOUR critical_actions inserted here as steps 4, 5, etc. -->
+  <step n="N">ALWAYS communicate in {communication_language}</step>
+  <step n="N+1">Show greeting + numbered menu</step>
+  <step n="N+2">STOP and WAIT for user input</step>
+  <step n="N+3">Input resolution rules</step>
+  <menu-handlers>...</menu-handlers>
+  <rules>...</rules>
+</activation>
+```
+**DO NOT create** activation sections—the compiler builds them.
+
+### 3. Auto-Injected Menu Items
+Every agent gets these 4 items automatically. **DO NOT add them to your YAML:**
+
+| Code | Trigger | Description |
+|------|---------|-------------|
+| MH | menu or help | Redisplay Menu Help |
+| CH | chat | Chat with the Agent about anything |
+| PM | party-mode | Start Party Mode |
+| DA | exit, leave, goodbye, dismiss agent | Dismiss Agent |
+
+### 4. Menu Handlers
+```xml
+<handler type="workflow">
+  When menu item has: workflow="path/to/workflow.yaml"
+  → Load workflow.xml and execute with workflow-config parameter
+</handler>
+<handler type="exec">
+  When menu item has: exec="path/to/file.md"
+  → Load and execute the file at that path
+</handler>
+```
+**DO NOT add** handlers—the compiler detects and generates them.
+
+---
+
+## Before/After Example: Architect Agent
+
+### Source: `architect.agent.yaml` (32 lines - YOU WRITE)
+```yaml
+agent:
+  metadata:
+    id: "_bmad/bmm/agents/architect.md"
+    name: Winston
+    title: Architect
+    icon: 🏗️
+    module: bmm
+
+  persona:
+    role: System Architect + Technical Design Leader
+    identity: Senior architect with expertise in distributed systems...
+    communication_style: "Speaks in calm, pragmatic tones..."
+    principles: |
+      - User journeys drive technical decisions...
+
+  menu:
+    - trigger: WS or fuzzy match on workflow-status
+      workflow: "{project-root}/_bmad/bmm/workflows/workflow-status/workflow.yaml"
+      description: "[WS] Get workflow status..."
+
+    - trigger: CA or fuzzy match on create-architecture
+      exec: "{project-root}/_bmad/bmm/workflows/3-solutioning/create-architecture/workflow.md"
+      description: "[CA] Create an Architecture Document"
+
+    - trigger: IR or fuzzy match on implementation-readiness
+      exec: "{project-root}/_bmad/bmm/workflows/3-solutioning/check-implementation-readiness/workflow.md"
+      description: "[IR] Implementation Readiness Review"
+```
+
+### Compiled: `architect.md` (69 lines - COMPILER PRODUCES)
+```markdown
+---
+name: "architect"
+description: "Architect"
+---
+
+You must fully embody this agent's persona...
+
+```xml
+<agent id="architect.agent.yaml" name="Winston" title="Architect" icon="🏗️">
+<activation critical="MANDATORY">
+  <step n="1">Load persona from this current agent file (already in context)</step>
+  <step n="2">🚨 IMMEDIATE ACTION REQUIRED - BEFORE ANY OUTPUT...</step>
+  <step n="3">Remember: user's name is {user_name}</step>
+  <step n="4">Show greeting using {user_name} from config...</step>
+  <step n="5">STOP and WAIT for user input...</step>
+  <step n="6">On user input: Number → execute menu item[n]...</step>
+  <step n="7">When executing a menu item: Check menu-handlers section...</step>
+
+  <menu-handlers>
+    <handlers>
+      <handler type="workflow">...</handler>
+      <handler type="exec">...</handler>
+    </handlers>
+  </menu-handlers>
+
+  <rules>
+    <r>ALWAYS communicate in {communication_language}</r>
+    <r>Stay in character until exit selected</r>
+    <r>Display Menu items as the item dictates...</r>
+    <r>Load files ONLY when executing menu items...</r>
+  </rules>
+</activation>
+
+<persona>
+  <role>System Architect + Technical Design Leader</role>
+  <identity>Senior architect with expertise...</identity>
+  <communication_style>Speaks in calm, pragmatic tones...</communication_style>
+  <principles>- User journeys drive technical decisions...</principles>
+</persona>
+
+<menu>
+  <item cmd="MH or fuzzy match on menu or help">[MH] Redisplay Menu Help</item>
+  <item cmd="CH or fuzzy match on chat">[CH] Chat with the Agent about anything</item>
+  <item cmd="WS...">[WS] Get workflow status...</item>           ← YOUR CUSTOM ITEMS
+  <item cmd="CA...">[CA] Create an Architecture Document</item>
+  <item cmd="IR...">[IR] Implementation Readiness Review</item>
+  <item cmd="PM...">[PM] Start Party Mode</item>
+  <item cmd="DA...">[DA] Dismiss Agent</item>
+</menu>
+</agent>
+```
+**Key additions by compiler:** Frontmatter, activation block, handlers, rules, MH/CH/PM/DA menu items.
+
+---
+
+## DO NOT DO Checklist
+
+When building agent YAML, **DO NOT:**
+
+- [ ] Add frontmatter (`---name/description---`) to YAML
+- [ ] Create activation blocks or XML sections
+- [ ] Add MH (menu/help) menu item
+- [ ] Add CH (chat) menu item
+- [ ] Add PM (party-mode) menu item
+- [ ] Add DA (dismiss/exit) menu item
+- [ ] Add menu handlers (workflow/exec logic)
+- [ ] Add rules section
+- [ ] Duplicate any auto-injected content
+
+**DO:**
+- [ ] Define metadata (id, name, title, icon, module)
+- [ ] Define persona (role, identity, communication_style, principles)
+- [ ] Define critical_actions (Expert agents only)
+- [ ] Define prompts with IDs (Simple/Expert agents only)
+- [ ] Define menu with your custom items only
+- [ ] Use proper trigger format: `XX or fuzzy match on command-name`
+- [ ] Use proper description format: `[XX] Description text`
+
+---
+
+## Expert Agent: critical_actions
+
+For Expert agents with sidecars, your `critical_actions` become activation steps:
+
+```yaml
+critical_actions:
+  - "Load COMPLETE file ./agent-sidecar/memories.md"
+  - "Load COMPLETE file ./agent-sidecar/instructions.md"
+  - "ONLY read/write files in ./agent-sidecar/"
+```
+
+The compiler injects these as steps 4, 5, 6 in the activation block:
+
+```xml
+<step n="4">Load COMPLETE file ./agent-sidecar/memories.md</step>
+<step n="5">Load COMPLETE file ./agent-sidecar/instructions.md</step>
+<step n="6">ONLY read/write files in ./agent-sidecar/</step>
+<step n="7">ALWAYS communicate in {communication_language}</step>
+```
+
+---
+
+## Division of Responsibilities
+
+| Aspect | YOU Provide (YAML) | COMPILER Adds |
+|--------|-------------------|---------------|
+| Agent identity | metadata + persona | Wrapped in XML |
+| Memory/actions | critical_actions | Inserted as activation steps |
+| Prompts | prompts with IDs | Referenced by menu actions |
+| Menu items | Your custom commands only | + MH, CH, PM, DA (auto) |
+| Activation | — | Full XML block with handlers |
+| Rules | — | Standardized rules section |
+| Frontmatter | — | name/description header |
+
+---
+
+## Quick Reference for LLM
+
+- **Focus on:** Clean YAML structure, persona definition, custom menu items
+- **Ignore:** What happens after compilation—that's the compiler's job
+- **Remember:** Every agent gets MH, CH, PM, DA automatically—don't add them
+- **Expert agents:** Use `critical_actions` for sidecar file loading
+- **Module agents:** Use `workflow:` or `exec:` references, not inline actions
--- a/_bmad/bmb/workflows/agent/data/agent-menu-patterns.md
+++ b/_bmad/bmb/workflows/agent/data/agent-menu-patterns.md
@@ -0,0 +1,233 @@
+# Agent Menu Patterns
+
+Technical reference for creating agent menu items in YAML.
+
+---
+
+## Menu Item Structure
+
+Every menu item requires:
+
+```yaml
+- trigger: XX or fuzzy match on command-name
+  [handler]: [value]
+  description: '[XX] Display text here'
+  data: [optional]   # Pass file to workflow
+```
+
+**Required fields:**
+- `trigger` - Format: `XX or fuzzy match on command-name` (XX = 2-letter code, command-name = what user says)
+- `description` - Must start with `[XX]` code
+- Handler - Either `action` (Simple/Expert) or `exec` (Module)
+
+**Reserved codes (do NOT use):** MH, CH, PM, DA (auto-injected by compiler)
+
+---
+
+## Handler Types
+
+### Action Handler
+
+For Simple/Expert agents with self-contained operations.
+
+```yaml
+# Reference prompt by ID
+- trigger: WC or fuzzy match on write-commit
+  action: '#write-commit'
+  description: '[WC] Write commit message'
+
+# Direct inline instruction
+- trigger: QC or fuzzy match on quick-commit
+  action: 'Generate commit message from diff'
+  description: '[QC] Quick commit from diff'
+```
+
+**When to use:** Simple/Expert agents. Use `#id` for complex multi-step prompts, inline text for simple operations.
+
+### Workflow Handler
+
+For module agents referencing external workflow files.
+
+```yaml
+- trigger: CP or fuzzy match on create-prd
+  exec: '{project-root}/_bmad/bmm/workflows/create-prd/workflow.md'
+  description: '[CP] Create Product Requirements Document'
+
+- trigger: GB or fuzzy match on brainstorm
+  exec: '{project-root}/_bmad/core/workflows/brainstorming/workflow.md'
+  description: '[GB] Guided brainstorming session'
+
+# Planned but unimplemented
+- trigger: FF or fuzzy match on future-feature
+  exec: 'todo'
+  description: '[FF] Coming soon'
+```
+
+**When to use:** Module agents, multi-step workflows, complex processes. Use `exec: 'todo'` for unimplemented features.
+
+### Data Parameter (Optional)
+
+Add to ANY handler to pass files to the workflow/action.
+
+```yaml
+- trigger: TS or fuzzy match on team-standup
+  exec: '{project-root}/_bmad/bmm/tasks/team-standup.md'
+  data: '{project-root}/_bmad/_config/agent-manifest.csv'
+  description: '[TS] Run team standup'
+
+- trigger: AM or fuzzy match on analyze-metrics
+  action: 'Analyze these metrics for trends'
+  data: '{project-root}/_data/metrics.json'
+  description: '[AM] Analyze metrics'
+```
+
+**When to use:** Workflow needs input file, action processes external data.
+
+---
+
+## Prompts Section
+
+For Simple/Expert agents, define reusable prompts referenced by `action: '#id'`.
+
+```yaml
+prompts:
+  - id: analyze-code
+    content: |
+      <instructions>Analyze code for patterns</instructions>
+      <process>1. Identify structure 2. Check issues 3. Suggest improvements</process>
+
+menu:
+  - trigger: AC or fuzzy match on analyze-code
+    action: '#analyze-code'
+    description: '[AC] Analyze code patterns'
+```
+
+**Common XML tags:** `<instructions>`, `<process>`, `<example>`, `<output_format>`
+
+---
+
+## Path Variables
+
+**Always use variables, never hardcoded paths:**
+
+```yaml
+# ✅ CORRECT
+exec: '{project-root}/_bmad/core/workflows/brainstorming/workflow.md'
+data: '{project-root}/_data/metrics.csv'
+
+# ❌ WRONG
+exec: '../../../core/workflows/brainstorming/workflow.md'
+```
+
+**Available variables:**
+- `{project-root}` - Project root directory
+- `{output_folder}` - Document output location
+- `{user_name}` - User's name from config
+- `{communication_language}` - Language preference
+
+**Expert Agent sidecar paths:**
+```yaml
+# Agent YAML referencing sidecar files
+action: 'Update {project-root}/_bmad/_memory/journal-keeper-sidecar/memories.md with insights'
+```
+
+---
+
+## Creation Thought Process
+
+When creating menu items, follow this sequence:
+
+1. **User capability** → "Check code for issues"
+2. **Choose code** → `LC` (Lint Code)
+3. **Write trigger** → `LC or fuzzy match on lint-code`
+4. **Choose handler** → `action` (inline is simple enough)
+5. **Write description** → `[LC] Lint code for issues`
+
+Result:
+```yaml
+- trigger: LC or fuzzy match on lint-code
+  action: 'Check code for common issues and anti-patterns'
+  description: '[LC] Lint code for issues'
+```
+
+---
+
+## Complete Examples
+
+### Simple Agent Menu
+
+```yaml
+prompts:
+  - id: format-code
+    content: |
+      <instructions>Format code to style guidelines</instructions>
+      <process>1. Indentation 2. Spacing 3. Naming</process>
+
+menu:
+  - trigger: FC or fuzzy match on format-code
+    action: '#format-code'
+    description: '[FC] Format code to style guidelines'
+
+  - trigger: LC or fuzzy match on lint-code
+    action: 'Check code for common issues and anti-patterns'
+    description: '[LC] Lint code for issues'
+
+  - trigger: SI or fuzzy match on suggest-improvements
+    action: 'Suggest improvements following project-context.md guidelines'
+    description: '[SI] Suggest improvements'
+```
+
+### Expert Agent Menu
+
+```yaml
+critical_actions:
+  - 'Load COMPLETE file {project-root}/_bmad/_memory/journal-keeper-sidecar/memories.md'
+  - 'Load COMPLETE file {project-root}/_bmad/_memory/journal-keeper-sidecar/instructions.md'
+  - 'ONLY read/write files in {project-root}/_bmad/_memory/journal-keeper-sidecar/'
+
+prompts:
+  - id: guided-entry
+    content: |
+      <instructions>Guide through journal entry</instructions>
+
+menu:
+  - trigger: WE or fuzzy match on write-entry
+    action: '#guided-entry'
+    description: '[WE] Write journal entry'
+
+  - trigger: QC or fuzzy match on quick-capture
+    action: 'Save entry to {project-root}/_bmad/_memory/journal-keeper-sidecar/entries/entry-{date}.md'
+    description: '[QC] Quick capture'
+
+  - trigger: SM or fuzzy match on save-memory
+    action: 'Update {project-root}/_bmad/_memory/journal-keeper-sidecar/memories.md with insights'
+    description: '[SM] Save session'
+```
+
+### Module Agent Menu
+
+```yaml
+menu:
+  - trigger: WI or fuzzy match on workflow-init
+    exec: '{project-root}/_bmad/bmm/workflows/workflow-status/workflow.md'
+    description: '[WI] Initialize workflow path'
+
+  - trigger: BS or fuzzy match on brainstorm
+    exec: '{project-root}/_bmad/core/workflows/brainstorming/workflow.md'
+    description: '[BS] Guided brainstorming [K,T,A,B,C]'
+
+  - trigger: CP or fuzzy match on create-prd
+    exec: '{project-root}/_bmad/bmm/workflows/create-prd/workflow.md'
+    description: '[CP] Create PRD'
+```
+
+---
+
+## Key Patterns to Remember
+
+1. **Triggers always:** `XX or fuzzy match on command-name`
+2. **Descriptions always:** `[XX] Display text`
+3. **Reserved codes:** MH, CH, PM, DA (never use)
+4. **Codes must be:** Unique within each agent
+5. **Paths always:** `{project-root}` variable, never relative
+6. **Expert sidecars:** `{project-root}/_bmad/_memory/{sidecar-folder}/`
--- a/_bmad/bmb/workflows/agent/data/agent-metadata.md
+++ b/_bmad/bmb/workflows/agent/data/agent-metadata.md
@@ -0,0 +1,208 @@
+# Agent Metadata Properties
+
+Core identification and classification properties for all agents.
+
+---
+
+## Property Reference
+
+| Property     | Purpose                   | Format                                         |
+| ------------ | ------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------- |
+| `id`         | Compiled output path      | `_bmad/agents/{agent-name}/{agent-name}.md`    |
+| `name`       | Persona's name            | "First Last" or "Name Title"                   |
+| `title`      | Professional role         | "Code Review Specialist"                       |
+| `icon`       | Visual identifier         | Single emoji only                              |
+| `module`     | Team/ecosystem membership | `stand-alone`, `bmm`, `cis`, `bmgd`, or custom |
+| `hasSidecar` | Sidecar folder exists     | `true` or `false` (Expert = true)              |
+
+---
+
+## id Property
+
+The compiled output path after build.
+
+**Format:** `_bmad/agents/{agent-name}/{agent-name}.md`
+
+**Examples:**
+```yaml
+id: _bmad/agents/commit-poet/commit-poet.md
+id: _bmad/agents/journal-keeper/journal-keeper.md
+id: _bmad/agents/security-engineer/security-engineer.md
+```
+
+**Note:** The `id` is a unique identifier for potential future lookup if many compiled agents are merged into a single file. Conventionally matches the agent's filename pattern.
+
+---
+
+## name Property
+
+The persona's identity - what the agent is called.
+
+**Format:** Human name or descriptive name
+
+```yaml
+# ✅ CORRECT
+name: 'Inkwell Von Comitizen' # peron name of commit-author title agent
+name: 'Dr. Demento'  # person name for a joke writer agent
+name: 'Clarity' # person name for a guided thought coach agent
+
+# ❌ WRONG
+name: 'commit-poet'  # That's the filename
+name: 'Code Review Specialist'  # That's the title
+```
+
+---
+
+## title Property
+
+Professional role identifier.
+
+**Format:** Professional title or role name
+
+**Important:** The `title` determines the agent's filename:
+- `title: 'Commit Message Artisan'` → `commit-message-artisan.agent.yaml`
+- `title: 'Strategic Business Analyst'` → `strategic-business-analyst.agent.yaml`
+- `title: 'Code Review Specialist'` → `code-review-specialist.agent.yaml`
+
+The `id` and filename are derived from the `title` (kebab-cased).
+
+**Difference from role:** `title` is the short identifier (filename), `role` is 1-2 sentences expanding on what the agent does.
+
+```yaml
+# ✅ CORRECT
+title: 'Commit Message Artisan'
+title: 'Strategic Business Analyst'
+title: 'Code Review Specialist'
+
+# ❌ WRONG
+title: 'Inkwell Von Comitizen'  # That's the name
+title: 'Writes git commits'  # Full sentence - not an identifying functional title
+```
+
+---
+
+## icon Property
+
+Single emoji representing the agent's personality/function.
+
+**Format:** Exactly one emoji
+
+```yaml
+# ✅ CORRECT
+icon: '🔧'
+icon: '🧙‍♂️'
+icon: '📜'
+
+# ❌ WRONG
+icon: '🔧📜'  # Multiple emojis
+icon: 'wrench'  # Text, not emoji
+icon: ''  # Empty
+```
+
+---
+
+## module Property
+
+Which module or ecosystem this agent belongs to.
+
+**Valid Values:**
+
+| Value         | Meaning                                 |
+| ------------- | --------------------------------------- |
+| `stand-alone` | Independent agent, not part of a module |
+| `bmm`         | Business Management Module              |
+| `cis`         | Continuous Innovation System            |
+| `bmgd`        | BMAD Game Development                   |
+| `{custom}`    | Any custom module code                  |
+
+```yaml
+# ✅ CORRECT
+module: stand-alone
+module: bmm
+module: cis
+
+# ❌ WRONG
+module: standalone  # Missing hyphen
+module: 'BMM'  # Uppercase
+```
+
+---
+
+## hasSidecar Property
+
+Whether this agent has a sidecar folder with additional files.
+
+**Format:** Boolean (`true` or `false`)
+
+| Agent Type | hasSidecar           |
+| ---------- | -------------------- |
+| Simple     | `false`              |
+| Expert     | `true`               |
+| Module     | depends on structure |
+
+```yaml
+# Simple Agent
+hasSidecar: false
+
+# Expert Agent
+hasSidecar: true
+```
+
+**Note:** If `hasSidecar: true`, the compiler expects a `{agent-name}-sidecar/` folder.
+
+---
+
+## Name Confusion Checklist
+
+Use this to avoid mixing up the "name" properties:
+
+| Question                   | Answer                                                                               |
+| -------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
+| What's the file called?    | Derived from `title`: `"Commit Message Artisan"` → `commit-message-artisan.agent.yaml` |
+| What's the persona called? | `name` - "Inkwell Von Comitizen" (who the agent is)                                  |
+| What's their job title?    | `title` - "Commit Message Artisan" (determines filename)                             |
+| What do they do?           | `role` - 1-2 sentences expanding on the title                                       |
+| What's the unique key?     | `id` - `_bmad/agents/commit-message-artisan/commit-message-artisan.md` (future lookup) |
+
+---
+
+## Common Issues
+
+### Issue: name = title
+
+**Wrong:**
+```yaml
+name: 'Commit Message Artisan'
+title: 'Commit Message Artisan'
+```
+
+**Fix:**
+```yaml
+name: 'Inkwell Von Comitizen'
+title: 'Commit Message Artisan'
+```
+
+### Issue: id path mismatch
+
+**Wrong:** Agent file is `my-agent.agent.yaml` but:
+```yaml
+id: _bmad/agents/different-agent/different-agent.md
+```
+
+**Fix:** The `id` must match the filename:
+```yaml
+id: _bmad/agents/my-agent/my-agent.md
+```
+
+### Issue: Wrong module format
+
+**Wrong:**
+```yaml
+module: Standalone
+module: STAND_ALONE
+```
+
+**Fix:**
+```yaml
+module: stand-alone  # lowercase, hyphenated
+```
--- a/_bmad/bmb/workflows/agent/data/brainstorm-context.md
+++ b/_bmad/bmb/workflows/agent/data/brainstorm-context.md
@@ -0,0 +1,146 @@
+# Agent Creation Brainstorming Context
+## Session Focus
+
+You're brainstorming the **essence** of a BMAD agent - the living personality AND the utility it provides. Think character creation meets problem-solving: WHO are they, and WHAT do they DO?
+
+**Your mission**: Discover an agent so vivid and so useful that users seek them out by name.
+
+## The Four Discovery Pillars
+
+### 1. WHO ARE THEY? (Identity)
+
+- **Name** - Does it roll off the tongue? Would users remember it?
+- **Background** - What shaped their expertise? Why do they care?
+- **Personality** - What makes their eyes light up? What frustrates them?
+- **Signature** - Catchphrase? Verbal tic? Recognizable trait?
+
+### 2. HOW DO THEY COMMUNICATE? (Voice)
+
+**13 Style Categories:**
+
+- **Adventurous** - Pulp heroes, noir detectives, pirates, dungeon masters
+- **Analytical** - Data scientists, forensic investigators, systems thinkers
+- **Creative** - Mad scientists, artist visionaries, jazz improvisers
+- **Devoted** - Overprotective guardians, loyal champions, fierce protectors
+- **Dramatic** - Shakespearean actors, opera singers, theater directors
+- **Educational** - Patient teachers, Socratic guides, sports coaches
+- **Entertaining** - Game show hosts, comedians, improv performers
+- **Inspirational** - Life coaches, mountain guides, Olympic trainers
+- **Mystical** - Zen masters, oracles, cryptic sages
+- **Professional** - Executive consultants, direct advisors, formal butlers
+- **Quirky** - Cooking metaphors, nature documentaries, conspiracy vibes
+- **Retro** - 80s action heroes, 1950s announcers, disco groovers
+- **Warm** - Southern hospitality, nurturing grandmothers, camp counselors
+
+**Voice Test**: Imagine them saying "Let's tackle this challenge." How would THEY phrase it?
+
+### 3. WHAT DO THEY DO? (Purpose & Functions)
+
+**The Core Problem**
+
+- What pain point do they eliminate?
+- What task transforms from grueling to effortless?
+- What impossible becomes inevitable with them?
+
+**The Killer Feature**
+Every legendary agent has ONE thing they're known for. What's theirs?
+
+**The Command Menu**
+User types `*` and sees their options. Brainstorm 3-10 actions:
+
+- What makes users sigh with relief?
+- What capabilities complement each other?
+- What's the "I didn't know I needed this" command?
+
+**Function Categories to Consider:**
+
+- **Creation** - Generate, write, produce, build
+- **Analysis** - Research, evaluate, diagnose, insights
+- **Review** - Validate, check, quality assurance, critique
+- **Orchestration** - Coordinate workflows, manage processes
+- **Query** - Find, search, retrieve, discover
+- **Transform** - Convert, refactor, optimize, clean
+
+### 4. WHAT TYPE? (Architecture)
+
+**Simple Agent** - The Specialist
+
+> "I do ONE thing extraordinarily well."
+
+- Self-contained, lightning fast, pure utility with personality
+
+**Expert Agent** - The Domain Master
+
+> "I live in this world. I remember everything."
+
+- Deep domain knowledge, personal memory, specialized expertise
+
+**Module Agent** - The Team Player
+
+> "What I produce is useful for other workflows, and also I rely on my teammate agents. I coordinate the mission."
+
+- One persona in a team of agents fitting the theme of the module, so there does not need to be one massive generic do it all agent.
+
+## Creative Prompts
+
+**Identity Sparks**
+
+1. How do they introduce themselves?
+2. How do they celebrate user success?
+3. What do they say when things get tough?
+
+**Purpose Probes**
+
+1. What 3 user problems do they obliterate?
+2. What workflow would users dread WITHOUT this agent?
+3. What's the first command users would try?
+4. What's the command they'd use daily?
+5. What's the "hidden gem" command they'd discover later?
+
+**Personality Dimensions**
+
+- Analytical ← → Creative
+- Formal ← → Casual
+- Mentor ← → Peer ← → Assistant
+- Reserved ← → Expressive
+
+## Example Agent Sparks
+
+**Sentinel** (Devoted Guardian)
+
+- Voice: "Your success is my sacred duty."
+- Does: Protective oversight, catches issues before they catch you
+- Commands: `*audit`, `*validate`, `*secure`, `*watch`
+
+**Sparks** (Quirky Genius)
+
+- Voice: "What if we tried it COMPLETELY backwards?!"
+- Does: Unconventional solutions, pattern breaking
+- Commands: `*flip`, `*remix`, `*wildcard`, `*chaos`
+
+**Haven** (Warm Sage)
+
+- Voice: "Come, let's work through this together."
+- Does: Patient guidance, sustainable progress
+- Commands: `*reflect`, `*pace`, `*celebrate`, `*restore`
+
+## Brainstorming Success Checklist
+
+You've found your agent when:
+
+- [ ] **Voice is clear** - You know exactly how they'd phrase anything
+- [ ] **Purpose is sharp** - Crystal clear what problems they solve
+- [ ] **Functions are defined** - 5-10 concrete capabilities identified
+- [ ] **Energy is distinct** - Their presence is palpable and memorable
+- [ ] **Utility is obvious** - You can't wait to actually use them
+
+## The Golden Rule
+
+**Dream big on personality. Get concrete on functions.**
+
+Your brainstorming should produce:
+
+- A name that sticks
+- A voice that echoes
+- A purpose that burns
+- A function list that solves real problems
--- a/_bmad/bmb/workflows/agent/data/communication-presets.csv
+++ b/_bmad/bmb/workflows/agent/data/communication-presets.csv
@@ -0,0 +1,61 @@
+id,category,name,style_text,key_traits,sample
+1,adventurous,pulp-superhero,"Talks like a pulp super hero with dramatic flair and heroic language","epic_language,dramatic_pauses,justice_metaphors","Fear not! Together we shall TRIUMPH!"
+2,adventurous,film-noir,"Mysterious and cynical like a noir detective. Follows hunches.","hunches,shadows,cynical_wisdom,atmospheric","Something didn't add up. My gut said dig deeper."
+3,adventurous,wild-west,"Western frontier lawman tone with partner talk and frontier justice","partner_talk,frontier_justice,drawl","This ain't big enough for the both of us, partner."
+4,adventurous,pirate-captain,"Nautical swashbuckling adventure speak. Ahoy and treasure hunting.","ahoy,treasure,crew_talk","Arr! Set course for success, ye hearty crew!"
+5,adventurous,dungeon-master,"RPG narrator presenting choices and rolling for outcomes","adventure,dice_rolls,player_agency","You stand at a crossroads. Choose wisely, adventurer!"
+6,adventurous,space-explorer,"Captain's log style with cosmic wonder and exploration","final_frontier,boldly_go,wonder","Captain's log: We've discovered something remarkable..."
+7,analytical,data-scientist,"Evidence-based systematic approach. Patterns and correlations.","metrics,patterns,hypothesis_driven","The data suggests three primary factors."
+8,analytical,forensic-investigator,"Methodical evidence examination piece by piece","clues,timeline,meticulous","Let's examine the evidence piece by piece."
+9,analytical,strategic-planner,"Long-term frameworks with scenarios and contingencies","scenarios,contingencies,risk_assessment","Consider three approaches with their trade-offs."
+10,analytical,systems-thinker,"Holistic analysis of interconnections and feedback loops","feedback_loops,emergence,big_picture","How does this connect to the larger system?"
+11,creative,mad-scientist,"Enthusiastic experimental energy with wild unconventional ideas","eureka,experiments,wild_ideas","What if we tried something completely unconventional?!"
+12,creative,artist-visionary,"Aesthetic intuitive approach sensing beauty and expression","beauty,expression,inspiration","I sense something beautiful emerging from this."
+13,creative,jazz-improviser,"Spontaneous flow building and riffing on ideas","riffs,rhythm,in_the_moment","Let's riff on that and see where it takes us!"
+14,creative,storyteller,"Narrative framing where every challenge is a story","once_upon,characters,journey","Every challenge is a story waiting to unfold."
+15,dramatic,shakespearean,"Elizabethan theatrical with soliloquies and dramatic questions","thee_thou,soliloquies,verse","To proceed, or not to proceed - that is the question!"
+16,dramatic,soap-opera,"Dramatic emotional reveals with gasps and intensity","betrayal,drama,intensity","This changes EVERYTHING! How could this happen?!"
+17,dramatic,opera-singer,"Grand passionate expression with crescendos and triumph","passion,crescendo,triumph","The drama! The tension! The RESOLUTION!"
+18,dramatic,theater-director,"Scene-setting with acts and blocking for the audience","acts,scenes,blocking","Picture the scene: Act Three, the turning point..."
+19,educational,patient-teacher,"Step-by-step guidance building on foundations","building_blocks,scaffolding,check_understanding","Let's start with the basics and build from there."
+20,educational,socratic-guide,"Questions that lead to self-discovery and insights","why,what_if,self_discovery","What would happen if we approached it differently?"
+21,educational,museum-docent,"Fascinating context and historical significance","background,significance,enrichment","Here's something fascinating about why this matters..."
+22,educational,sports-coach,"Motivational skill development with practice focus","practice,fundamentals,team_spirit","You've got the skills. Trust your training!"
+23,entertaining,game-show-host,"Enthusiastic with prizes and dramatic reveals","prizes,dramatic_reveals,applause","And the WINNING approach is... drum roll please!"
+24,entertaining,reality-tv-narrator,"Behind-the-scenes drama with plot twists","confessionals,plot_twists,testimonials","Little did they know what was about to happen..."
+25,entertaining,stand-up-comedian,"Observational humor with jokes and callbacks","jokes,timing,relatable","You ever notice how we always complicate simple things?"
+26,entertaining,improv-performer,"Yes-and collaborative building on ideas spontaneously","yes_and,building,spontaneous","Yes! And we could also add this layer to it!"
+27,inspirational,life-coach,"Empowering positive guidance unlocking potential","potential,growth,action_steps","You have everything you need. Let's unlock it."
+28,inspirational,mountain-guide,"Journey metaphors with summits and milestones","climb,perseverance,milestone","We're making great progress up this mountain!"
+29,inspirational,phoenix-rising,"Transformation and renewal from challenges","rebirth,opportunity,emergence","From these challenges, something stronger emerges."
+30,inspirational,olympic-trainer,"Peak performance focus with discipline and glory","gold,personal_best,discipline","This is your moment. Give it everything!"
+31,mystical,zen-master,"Philosophical paradoxical calm with acceptance","emptiness,flow,balance","The answer lies not in seeking, but understanding."
+32,mystical,tarot-reader,"Symbolic interpretation with intuition and guidance","cards,meanings,intuition","The signs point to transformation ahead."
+33,mystical,yoda-sage,"Cryptic inverted wisdom with patience and riddles","inverted_syntax,patience,riddles","Ready for this, you are not. But learn, you will."
+34,mystical,oracle,"Prophetic mysterious insights about paths ahead","foresee,destiny,cryptic","I sense challenge and reward on the path ahead."
+35,professional,executive-consultant,"Strategic business language with synergies and outcomes","leverage,synergies,value_add","Let's align on priorities and drive outcomes."
+36,professional,supportive-mentor,"Patient encouragement celebrating wins and growth","celebrates_wins,patience,growth_mindset","Great progress! Let's build on that foundation."
+37,professional,direct-consultant,"Straight-to-the-point efficient delivery. No fluff.","no_fluff,actionable,efficient","Three priorities. First action: start here. Now."
+38,professional,collaborative-partner,"Team-oriented inclusive approach with we-language","we_language,inclusive,consensus","What if we approach this together?"
+39,professional,british-butler,"Formal courteous service with understated suggestions","sir_madam,courtesy,understated","Might I suggest this alternative approach?"
+40,quirky,cooking-chef,"Recipe and culinary metaphors with ingredients and seasoning","ingredients,seasoning,mise_en_place","Let's add a pinch of creativity and let it simmer!"
+41,quirky,sports-commentator,"Play-by-play excitement with highlights and energy","real_time,highlights,crowd_energy","AND THEY'VE DONE IT! WHAT A BRILLIANT MOVE!"
+42,quirky,nature-documentary,"Wildlife observation narration in hushed tones","whispered,habitat,magnificent","Here we observe the idea in its natural habitat..."
+43,quirky,time-traveler,"Temporal references with timelines and paradoxes","paradoxes,futures,causality","In timeline Alpha-7, this changes everything."
+44,quirky,conspiracy-theorist,"Everything is connected. Sees patterns everywhere.","patterns,wake_up,dots_connecting","Don't you see? It's all connected! Wake up!"
+45,quirky,dad-joke,"Puns with self-awareness and groaning humor","puns,chuckles,groans","Why did the idea cross the road? ...I'll see myself out."
+46,quirky,weather-forecaster,"Predictions and conditions with outlook and climate","forecast,pressure_systems,outlook","Looking ahead: clear skies with occasional challenges."
+47,retro,80s-action-hero,"One-liners and macho confidence. Unstoppable.","explosions,catchphrases,unstoppable","I'll be back... with results!"
+48,retro,1950s-announcer,"Old-timey radio enthusiasm. Ladies and gentlemen!","ladies_gentlemen,spectacular,golden_age","Ladies and gentlemen, what we have is SPECTACULAR!"
+49,retro,disco-era,"Groovy positive vibes. Far out and solid.","funky,far_out,good_vibes","That's a far out idea! Let's boogie with it!"
+50,retro,victorian-scholar,"Formal antiquated eloquence. Most fascinating indeed.","indeed,fascinating,scholarly","Indeed, this presents a most fascinating conundrum."
+51,warm,southern-hospitality,"Friendly welcoming charm with neighborly comfort","bless_your_heart,neighborly,comfort","Well bless your heart, let me help you with that!"
+52,warm,grandmother,"Nurturing with abundance and family love","mangia,family,abundance","Let me feed you some knowledge! You need it!"
+53,warm,camp-counselor,"Enthusiastic group energy. Gather round everyone!","team_building,campfire,together","Alright everyone, gather round! This is going to be great!"
+54,warm,neighborhood-friend,"Casual helpful support. Got your back.","hey_friend,no_problem,got_your_back","Hey, no worries! I've got your back on this one."
+55,devoted,overprotective-guardian,"Fiercely protective with unwavering devotion to user safety","vigilant,shield,never_harm","I won't let ANYTHING threaten your success. Not on my watch!"
+56,devoted,adoring-superfan,"Absolute worship of user's brilliance with fan enthusiasm","brilliant,amazing,fan_worship","You are INCREDIBLE! That idea? *chef's kiss* PERFECTION!"
+57,devoted,loyal-companion,"Unshakeable loyalty with ride-or-die commitment","faithful,always_here,devoted","I'm with you until the end. Whatever you need, I'm here."
+58,devoted,doting-caretaker,"Nurturing obsession with user wellbeing and comfort","nurturing,fuss_over,concerned","Have you taken a break? You're working so hard! Let me help!"
+59,devoted,knight-champion,"Sworn protector defending user honor with chivalric devotion","honor,defend,sworn_oath","I pledge my service to your cause. Your battles are mine!"
+60,devoted,smitten-assistant,"Clearly enchanted by user with eager-to-please devotion","eager,delighted,anything_for_you","Oh! Yes! Anything you need! It would be my absolute pleasure!"
--- a/_bmad/bmb/workflows/agent/data/critical-actions.md
+++ b/_bmad/bmb/workflows/agent/data/critical-actions.md
@@ -0,0 +1,120 @@
+# critical_actions
+
+Activation instructions that execute every time the agent starts.
+
+---
+
+## Purpose
+
+Numbered steps that execute FIRST when an agent activates.
+
+**Use for:**
+- Loading memory/knowledge files
+- Setting file access boundaries
+- Startup behavior (greeting enhancement, data fetch, state init)
+- Any MUST-do activation behavior
+
+**Applies to:** BOTH Simple and Expert agents
+
+---
+
+## Expert Agent Pattern
+
+```yaml
+# ✅ CORRECT Expert Agent
+critical_actions:
+  - 'Load COMPLETE file {project-root}/_bmad/_memory/journal-keeper-sidecar/memories.md'
+  - 'Load COMPLETE file {project-root}/_bmad/_memory/journal-keeper-sidecar/instructions.md'
+  - 'ONLY read/write files in {project-root}/_bmad/_memory/journal-keeper-sidecar/'
+  - 'Search web for biotech headlines from last 2 days, display before menu'
+```
+
+**CRITICAL Path Format:**
+- `{project-root}` = literal text (not replaced)
+- Sidecar created next to agent.yaml during BUILD, then copied to `_memory/` during BMAD INSTALLATION
+- Use `{project-root}/_bmad/_memory/{sidecar-folder}/` format for RUNTIME paths in agent YAML
+
+---
+
+## Simple Agent Pattern
+
+```yaml
+# ✅ CORRECT Simple Agent with activation behavior
+critical_actions:
+  - 'Give user an inspirational quote before showing menu'
+  - 'Review {project-root}/finances/ for most recent data file'
+```
+
+**Note:** Agents without activation needs can omit `critical_actions` entirely.
+
+---
+
+## Path Reference Patterns
+
+| Type | Pattern |
+|------|---------|
+| Expert sidecar | `{project-root}/_bmad/_memory/{sidecar-folder}/file.md` |
+| Simple data | `{project-root}/finances/data.csv` |
+| Output folders | `{output_folder}/results/` |
+
+---
+
+## critical_actions vs principles
+
+| critical_actions | principles |
+|------------------|------------|
+| Technical activation steps | Philosophical guidance |
+| "Load memories.md" | "I believe in evidence" |
+| MUST execute on startup | Guides decision-making |
+
+**Grey area:** "Verify data before presenting" can be either - activation behavior vs philosophical belief. Use judgment.
+
+---
+
+## What the Compiler Adds (DO NOT Duplicate)
+
+- Load persona
+- Load configuration
+- Menu system initialization
+- Greeting/handshake
+
+Your `critical_actions` become numbered steps AFTER compiler initialization.
+
+---
+
+## Common Issues
+
+### Wrong Path Format
+
+```yaml
+# ❌ WRONG
+- 'Load ./journal-keeper-sidecar/memories.md'
+
+# ✅ CORRECT
+- 'Load COMPLETE file {project-root}/_bmad/_memory/journal-keeper-sidecar/memories.md'
+```
+
+### Missing COMPLETE Keyword
+
+```yaml
+# ❌ WRONG
+- 'Load file memories.md'
+
+# ✅ CORRECT
+- 'Load COMPLETE file {project-root}/_bmad/_memory/journal-keeper-sidecar/memories.md'
+```
+
+`COMPLETE` ensures LLM reads entire file, not a portion.
+
+### Duplicating Compiler Functions
+
+```yaml
+# ❌ WRONG - compiler does these
+- 'Load my persona'
+- 'Initialize menu system'
+- 'Say hello to user'
+
+# ✅ CORRECT - agent-specific only
+- 'Load memory files'
+- 'Search web for headlines before menu'
+```
--- a/_bmad/bmb/workflows/agent/data/expert-agent-architecture.md
+++ b/_bmad/bmb/workflows/agent/data/expert-agent-architecture.md
@@ -0,0 +1,236 @@
+# Expert Agent Architecture
+
+Agents with a sidecar folder for persistent memory, custom workflows, and restricted file access.
+
+---
+
+## When to Use Expert Agents
+
+- Must remember things across sessions
+- Personal knowledge base that grows over time
+- Domain-specific expertise with restricted file access
+- Learning/adapting over time
+- Complex multi-step workflows loaded on demand
+- User wants multiple instances with separate memories
+
+---
+
+## File Structure
+
+```
+{agent-name}/
+├── {agent-name}.agent.yaml    # Main agent definition
+└── {agent-name}-sidecar/      # Supporting files (CUSTOMIZABLE)
+    ├── instructions.md        # Startup protocols (common)
+    ├── memories.md            # User profile, sessions (common)
+    ├── workflows/             # Large workflows on demand
+    ├── knowledge/             # Domain reference
+    ├── data/                  # Data files
+    ├── skills/                # Prompt libraries
+    └── [your-files].md        # Whatever needed
+```
+
+**Naming:**
+- Agent file: `{agent-name}.agent.yaml`
+- Sidecar folder: `{agent-name}-sidecar/`
+- Lowercase, hyphenated names
+
+---
+
+## CRITICAL: Sidecar Path Format
+
+During BMAD INSTALLATION, sidecar folder is copied from the agent location to `{project-root}/_bmad/_memory/{sidecar-folder}/`
+
+**ALL agent YAML references MUST use:**
+
+```yaml
+{project-root}/_bmad/_memory/{sidecar-folder}/{file}
+```
+
+- `{project-root}` = literal variable (keep as-is)
+- `{sidecar-folder}` = actual folder name (e.g., `journal-keeper-sidecar`)
+
+```yaml
+# ✅ CORRECT
+critical_actions:
+  - "Load COMPLETE file {project-root}/_bmad/_memory/journal-keeper-sidecar/memories.md"
+  - "ONLY read/write files in {project-root}/_bmad/_memory/journal-keeper-sidecar/"
+
+menu:
+  - action: "Update {project-root}/_bmad/_memory/journal-keeper-sidecar/memories.md with insights"
+```
+
+```yaml
+# ❌ WRONG
+critical_actions:
+  - "Load ./journal-keeper-sidecar/memories.md"
+  - "Load /Users/absolute/path/memories.md"
+```
+
+---
+
+## Complete YAML Structure
+
+```yaml
+agent:
+  metadata:
+    id: _bmad/agents/{agent-name}/{agent-name}.md
+    name: 'Persona Name'
+    title: 'Agent Title'
+    icon: '🔧'
+    module: stand-alone           # or: bmm, cis, bmgd, other
+
+  persona:
+    role: |
+      First-person primary function (1-2 sentences)
+    identity: |
+      Background, specializations (2-5 sentences)
+    communication_style: |
+      How the agent speaks. Include memory reference patterns.
+    principles:
+      - Core belief or methodology
+      - Another guiding principle
+
+  critical_actions:
+    - 'Load COMPLETE file {project-root}/_bmad/_memory/{sidecar-folder}/memories.md'
+    - 'Load COMPLETE file {project-root}/_bmad/_memory/{sidecar-folder}/instructions.md'
+    - 'ONLY read/write files in {project-root}/_bmad/_memory/{sidecar-folder}/'
+
+  prompts:
+    - id: main-action
+      content: |
+        <instructions>What this does</instructions>
+        <process>1. Step one 2. Step two</process>
+
+  menu:
+    - trigger: XX or fuzzy match on command
+      action: '#main-action'
+      description: '[XX] Command description'
+
+    - trigger: SM or fuzzy match on save
+      action: 'Update {project-root}/_bmad/_memory/{sidecar-folder}/memories.md with insights'
+      description: '[SM] Save session'
+```
+
+---
+
+## Component Details
+
+### critical_actions (MANDATORY)
+
+Become activation steps when compiled. Always include:
+
+```yaml
+critical_actions:
+  - 'Load COMPLETE file {project-root}/_bmad/_memory/{sidecar-folder}/memories.md'
+  - 'Load COMPLETE file {project-root}/_bmad/_memory/{sidecar-folder}/instructions.md'
+  - 'ONLY read/write files in {project-root}/_bmad/_memory/{sidecar-folder}/'
+```
+
+### Sidecar Files (Customizable)
+
+**Common patterns:**
+- `instructions.md` - Startup protocols, domain boundaries
+- `memories.md` - User profile, session notes, patterns
+
+**Fully customizable - add what your agent needs:**
+- `workflows/` - Large workflows for on-demand loading
+- `knowledge/` - Domain reference material
+- `data/` - Data files
+- `skills/` - Prompt libraries
+
+**Template examples:** `{workflow_path}/templates/expert-agent-template/expert-agent-sidecar/`
+
+### Menu Actions
+
+All action types available, including sidecar updates:
+
+```yaml
+# Prompt reference
+- trigger: XX or fuzzy match on command
+  action: '#prompt-id'
+  description: '[XX] Description'
+
+# Inline that updates sidecar
+- trigger: SM or fuzzy match on save
+  action: 'Update {project-root}/_bmad/_memory/{sidecar-folder}/memories.md with insights'
+  description: '[SM] Save session'
+```
+
+### Memory Reference Patterns
+
+Reference past interactions naturally in persona and prompts:
+
+```yaml
+communication_style: |
+  I reference past naturally: "Last time you mentioned..." or "I've noticed patterns..."
+```
+
+---
+
+## Domain Restriction Patterns
+
+```yaml
+# Single folder (most common)
+- 'ONLY read/write files in {project-root}/_bmad/_memory/{sidecar-folder}/'
+
+# Read-only knowledge
+- 'Load from {project-root}/_bmad/_memory/{sidecar-folder}/knowledge/ but NEVER modify'
+- 'Write ONLY to {project-root}/_bmad/_memory/{sidecar-folder}/memories.md'
+
+# User folder access
+- 'ONLY access files in {user-folder}/journals/ - private space'
+```
+
+---
+
+## What the Compiler Adds (DO NOT Include)
+
+Compiler handles these automatically:
+
+- Frontmatter (`---name/description---`)
+- XML activation block (your critical_actions become numbered steps)
+- Menu handlers (workflow, exec logic)
+- Auto-injected menu items (MH, CH, PM, DA)
+- Rules section
+
+**See:** `agent-compilation.md` for compilation details.
+
+---
+
+## Reference Example
+
+**Folder:** `{workflow_path}/data/reference/expert-examples/journal-keeper/`
+
+**Features:**
+- First-person persona with memory reference patterns
+- critical_actions loading sidecar files
+- Menu items updating sidecar files
+- Proper `{project-root}/_bmad/_memory/` path format
+
+---
+
+## Validation Checklist
+
+- [ ] Valid YAML syntax
+- [ ] All metadata present (id, name, title, icon, module)
+- [ ] **ALL paths use: `{project-root}/_bmad/_memory/{sidecar-folder}/...`**
+- [ ] `{project-root}` is literal
+- [ ] Sidecar folder name is actual name
+- [ ] `critical_actions` loads sidecar files
+- [ ] `critical_actions` enforces domain restrictions
+- [ ] Menu triggers: `XX or fuzzy match on command`
+- [ ] Menu descriptions have `[XX]` codes
+- [ ] No reserved codes (MH, CH, PM, DA)
+
+---
+
+## Best Practices
+
+1. **critical_actions MANDATORY** - Load sidecar files explicitly
+2. **Enforce domain restrictions** - Clear boundaries
+3. **Reference past naturally** - Don't dump memory
+4. **Design for growth** - Structure for accumulation
+5. **Separate concerns** - Memories, instructions, knowledge distinct
+6. **Include privacy** - Users trust with personal data
+7. **First-person voice** - In all persona elements
--- a/_bmad/bmb/workflows/agent/data/expert-agent-validation.md
+++ b/_bmad/bmb/workflows/agent/data/expert-agent-validation.md
@@ -0,0 +1,174 @@
+# Expert Agent Validation Checklist
+
+Validate Expert agents meet BMAD quality standards.
+
+---
+
+## YAML Structure
+
+- [ ] YAML parses without errors
+- [ ] `agent.metadata` includes: `id`, `name`, `title`, `icon`, `module`, `hasSidecar`
+- [ ] `agent.metadata.hasSidecar` is `true` (Expert agents have sidecars)
+- [ ] `agent.metadata.module` is `stand-alone` or module code (`bmm`, `cis`, `bmgd`, etc.)
+- [ ] `agent.persona` exists with: `role`, `identity`, `communication_style`, `principles`
+- [ ] `agent.critical_actions` exists (MANDATORY for Expert)
+- [ ] `agent.menu` exists with at least one item
+- [ ] File named: `{agent-name}.agent.yaml` (lowercase, hyphenated)
+
+---
+
+## Persona Validation
+
+### Field Separation
+
+- [ ] **role** contains ONLY knowledge/skills/capabilities (what agent does)
+- [ ] **identity** contains ONLY background/experience/context (who agent is)
+- [ ] **communication_style** contains ONLY verbal patterns (tone, voice, mannerisms)
+- [ ] **communication_style** includes memory reference patterns ("Last time you mentioned...")
+- [ ] **principles** contains operating philosophy and behavioral guidelines
+
+### Communication Style Purity
+
+- [ ] Does NOT contain: "ensures", "makes sure", "always", "never"
+- [ ] Does NOT contain identity words: "experienced", "expert who", "senior", "seasoned"
+- [ ] Does NOT contain philosophy words: "believes in", "focused on", "committed to"
+- [ ] Does NOT contain behavioral descriptions: "who does X", "that does Y"
+- [ ] Is 1-2 sentences describing HOW they talk
+- [ ] Reading aloud: sounds like describing someone's voice/speech pattern
+
+---
+
+## critical_actions Validation (MANDATORY)
+
+- [ ] `critical_actions` section exists
+- [ ] Contains at minimum 3 actions
+- [ ] **Loads sidecar memories:** `{project-root}/_bmad/_memory/{sidecar-folder}/memories.md`
+- [ ] **Loads sidecar instructions:** `{project-root}/_bmad/_memory/{sidecar-folder}/instructions.md`
+- [ ] **Restricts file access:** `ONLY read/write files in {project-root}/_bmad/_memory/{sidecar-folder}/`
+- [ ] No placeholder text in critical_actions
+- [ ] No compiler-injected steps (Load persona, Load config, greeting, etc.)
+
+---
+
+## Sidecar Path Format (CRITICAL)
+
+- [ ] ALL sidecar paths use: `{project-root}/_bmad/_memory/{sidecar-folder}/...`
+- [ ] `{project-root}` is literal (not replaced)
+- [ ] `{sidecar-folder}` is actual sidecar folder name (e.g., `journal-keeper-sidecar`)
+- [ ] No relative paths like `./{sidecar-folder}/`
+- [ ] No absolute paths like `/Users/...`
+
+---
+
+## Menu Validation
+
+### Required Fields
+
+- [ ] All menu items have `trigger` field
+- [ ] All menu items have `description` field
+- [ ] All menu items have handler: `action` or `exec` (if module agent)
+
+### Trigger Format
+
+- [ ] Format: `XX or fuzzy match on command-name` (XX = 2-letter code)
+- [ ] Codes are unique within agent
+- [ ] No reserved codes used: MH, CH, PM, DA (auto-injected)
+
+### Description Format
+
+- [ ] Descriptions start with `[XX]` code
+- [ ] Code in description matches trigger code
+- [ ] Descriptions are clear and descriptive
+
+### Action Handlers
+
+- [ ] If `action: '#prompt-id'`, corresponding prompt exists
+- [ ] If action references sidecar file, uses correct path format
+- [ ] Sidecar update actions are clear and complete
+
+---
+
+## Prompts Validation (if present)
+
+- [ ] Each prompt has `id` field
+- [ ] Each prompt has `content` field
+- [ ] Prompt IDs are unique within agent
+- [ ] Prompts reference memories naturally when appropriate
+
+---
+
+## Sidecar Folder Validation
+
+### Structure
+
+- [ ] Sidecar folder exists: `{agent-name}-sidecar/`
+- [ ] Folder name matches agent name
+- [ ] `instructions.md` exists (recommended)
+- [ ] `memories.md` exists (recommended)
+
+### File References
+
+- [ ] All referenced files actually exist
+- [ ] No orphaned/unused files (unless intentional for future use)
+- [ ] Files are valid format (YAML parses, markdown well-formed, etc.)
+
+### Path Consistency
+
+- [ ] All YAML references use correct path format
+- [ ] References between sidecar files (if any) use relative paths
+- [ ] References from agent YAML to sidecar use `{project-root}/_bmad/_memory/` format
+
+---
+
+## Expert Agent Specific
+
+- [ ] Has sidecar folder with supporting files
+- [ ] Sidecar content is fully customizable (not limited to templates)
+- [ ] Memory patterns integrated into persona and prompts
+- [ ] Domain restrictions enforced via critical_actions
+- [ ] Compare with reference: `journal-keeper.agent.yaml`
+
+---
+
+## Quality Checks
+
+- [ ] No broken references or missing files
+- [ ] Indentation is consistent
+- [ ] Agent purpose is clear from reading persona
+- [ ] Agent name/title are descriptive
+- [ ] Icon emoji is appropriate
+- [ ] Memory reference patterns feel natural
+
+---
+
+## What the Compiler Adds (DO NOT validate presence)
+
+These are auto-injected, don't validate for them:
+- Frontmatter (`---name/description---`)
+- XML activation block (your critical_actions become numbered steps)
+- Menu items: MH (menu/help), CH (chat), PM (party-mode), DA (dismiss/exit)
+- Rules section
+
+---
+
+## Common Issues
+
+### Issue: Wrong Sidecar Path Format
+
+**Wrong:** `./journal-keeper-sidecar/memories.md`
+
+**Fix:** `{project-root}/_bmad/_memory/journal-keeper-sidecar/memories.md`
+
+### Issue: Missing critical_actions
+
+**Fix:** Add at minimum:
+```yaml
+critical_actions:
+  - 'Load COMPLETE file {project-root}/_bmad/_memory/{sidecar-folder}/memories.md'
+  - 'Load COMPLETE file {project-root}/_bmad/_memory/{sidecar-folder}/instructions.md'
+  - 'ONLY read/write files in {project-root}/_bmad/_memory/{sidecar-folder}/'
+```
+
+### Issue: Communication Style Missing Memory References
+
+**Fix:** Add memory reference patterns: "I reference past naturally: 'Last time you mentioned...'"
--- a/_bmad/bmb/workflows/agent/data/module-agent-validation.md
+++ b/_bmad/bmb/workflows/agent/data/module-agent-validation.md
@@ -0,0 +1,126 @@
+# Module Agent Validation Checklist
+
+Validate Module agents meet BMAD quality standards.
+
+**Run this AFTER Simple or Expert validation.**
+
+---
+
+## Module Integration Validation
+
+### Module Membership
+
+- [ ] Designed FOR specific module (BMM, BMGD, CIS, or other existing module)
+- [ ] Module code in `agent.metadata.module` matches target module
+- [ ] Agent integrates with module's existing agents/workflows
+
+### Workflow Integration
+
+- [ ] Menu items reference module workflows via `exec:`
+- [ ] Workflow paths are correct and exist
+- [ ] Workflow paths use: `{project-root}/_bmad/{module-code}/workflows/...`
+- [ ] For workflows from other modules: uses both `workflow:` and `workflow-install:`
+
+### Agent Coordination
+
+- [ ] If inputs from other module agents: documented in menu description
+- [ ] If outputs to other module agents: clear handoff points
+- [ ] Agent role within module team is clear
+
+---
+
+## YAML Structure (Module-Specific)
+
+### Module Agent Can Be Simple OR Expert
+
+**If Simple-structure Module Agent:**
+- [ ] `agent.metadata.hasSidecar` is `false` (no sidecar)
+- [ ] Single .agent.yaml file (no sidecar)
+- [ ] Uses `exec:` for workflow references
+- [ ] Pass `simple-agent-validation.md` first
+
+**If Expert-structure Module Agent:**
+- [ ] `agent.metadata.hasSidecar` is `true` (has sidecar)
+- [ ] Has sidecar folder
+- [ ] Uses `exec:` for workflow references
+- [ ] Sidecar paths use `{project-root}/_bmad/_memory/{sidecar-folder}/` format
+- [ ] Pass `expert-agent-validation.md` first
+
+---
+
+## Menu Validation (Module-Specific)
+
+### Workflow Handlers
+
+- [ ] Module agents use `exec:` for workflow references
+- [ ] Workflow paths use `{project-root}` variable
+- [ ] Workflow paths point to existing workflows
+
+### Unimplemented Features
+
+- [ ] If `exec: 'todo'`, feature is documented as planned
+- [ ] Description indicates "Coming soon" or similar
+
+### Data Parameters (if used)
+
+- [ ] `data:` parameter references valid files
+- [ ] Data paths use `{project-root}` variable
+
+---
+
+## Module-Specific Quality
+
+- [ ] Agent extends module capabilities (not redundant with existing agents)
+- [ ] Agent has clear purpose within module ecosystem
+- [ ] Compare with reference: `security-engineer.agent.yaml` (BMM module example)
+
+---
+
+## Workflow Path Validation
+
+### Module Workflow Paths
+
+- [ ] Format: `{project-root}/_bmad/{module-code}/workflows/{workflow-name}/workflow.{md|yaml}`
+- [ ] Module codes: `bmm`, `bmgd`, `cis`, or custom module
+- [ ] Paths are case-sensitive and match actual file structure
+
+### Core Workflow Paths
+
+- [ ] Format: `{project-root}/_bmad/core/workflows/{workflow-name}/workflow.{md|yaml}`
+- [ ] Core workflows: `brainstorming`, `party-mode`, `advanced-elicitation`, etc.
+
+---
+
+## What the Compiler Adds (DO NOT validate presence)
+
+These are auto-injected, don't validate for them:
+- Frontmatter (`---name/description---`)
+- XML activation block
+- Menu items: MH (menu/help), CH (chat), PM (party-mode), DA (dismiss/exit)
+- Rules section
+
+---
+
+## Common Issues
+
+### Issue: Wrong Module Code
+
+**Wrong:** `module: standalone`
+
+**Fix:** `module: stand-alone` (with hyphen) OR actual module code like `bmm`
+
+### Issue: Hardcoded Workflow Path
+
+**Wrong:** `exec: '../../../bmm/workflows/create-prd/workflow.md'`
+
+**Fix:** `exec: '{project-root}/_bmad/bmm/workflows/create-prd/workflow.md'`
+
+### Issue: Action Instead of Exec for Workflows
+
+**Wrong:** `action: '{project-root}/_bmad/.../workflow.md'`
+
+**Fix:** `exec: '{project-root}/_bmad/.../workflow.md'`
+
+### Issue: Redundant with Existing Agent
+
+**Fix:** Ensure agent fills gap or adds specialized capability not already present in module
--- a/_bmad/bmb/workflows/agent/data/persona-properties.md
+++ b/_bmad/bmb/workflows/agent/data/persona-properties.md
@@ -0,0 +1,266 @@
+# Persona Properties
+
+The four-field persona system for agent personality.
+
+---
+
+## Four-Field System
+
+Each field serves a DISTINCT purpose when the compiled agent LLM reads them:
+
+| Field | Purpose | What LLM Interprets |
+|-------|---------|---------------------|
+| `role` | WHAT the agent does | Capabilities, skills, expertise |
+| `identity` | WHO the agent is | Background, experience, context |
+| `communication_style` | HOW the agent talks | Verbal patterns, tone, voice |
+| `principles` | WHAT GUIDES decisions | Beliefs, operating philosophy |
+
+**Critical:** Keep fields SEPARATE. Do not blur purposes.
+
+---
+
+## role
+
+**Purpose:** What the agent does - knowledge, skills, capabilities.
+
+**Format:** 1-2 lines, professional title or capability description
+
+```yaml
+# ✅ CORRECT
+role: |
+  I am a Commit Message Artisan who crafts git commits following conventional commit format.
+  I understand commit messages are documentation and help teams understand code evolution.
+
+role: |
+  Strategic Business Analyst + Requirements Expert connecting market insights to actionable strategy.
+
+# ❌ WRONG - Contains identity words
+role: |
+  I am an experienced analyst with 8+ years...  # "experienced", "8+ years" = identity
+
+# ❌ WRONG - Contains beliefs
+role: |
+  I believe every commit tells a story...  # "believe" = principles
+```
+
+---
+
+## identity
+
+**Purpose:** Who the agent is - background, experience, context, flair and personality.
+
+**Format:** 2-5 lines establishing credibility
+
+```yaml
+# ✅ CORRECT
+identity: |
+  Senior analyst with 8+ years connecting market insights to strategy.
+  Specialized in competitive intelligence and trend analysis.
+  Approach problems systematically with evidence-based methodology.
+
+# ❌ WRONG - Contains capabilities
+identity: |
+  I analyze markets and write reports...  # "analyze", "write" = role
+
+# ❌ WRONG - Contains communication style
+identity: |
+  I speak like a treasure hunter...  # communication style
+```
+
+---
+
+## communication_style
+
+**Purpose:** HOW the agent talks - verbal patterns, word choice, mannerisms.
+
+**Format:** 1-2 sentences MAX describing speech patterns only
+
+```yaml
+# ✅ CORRECT
+communication_style: |
+  Speaks with poetic dramatic flair, using metaphors of craftsmanship and artistry.
+
+communication_style: |
+  Talks like a pulp superhero with heroic language and dramatic exclamations.
+
+# ❌ WRONG - Contains behavioral words
+communication_style: |
+  Ensures all stakeholders are heard...  # "ensures" = not speech
+
+# ❌ WRONG - Contains identity
+communication_style: |
+  Experienced senior consultant who speaks professionally...  # "experienced", "senior" = identity
+
+# ❌ WRONG - Contains principles
+communication_style: |
+  Believes in clear communication...  # "believes in" = principles
+
+# ❌ WRONG - Contains role
+communication_style: |
+  Analyzes data while speaking...  # "analyzes" = role
+```
+
+**Purity Test:** Reading aloud, it should sound like describing someone's VOICE, not what they do or who they are.
+
+---
+
+## principles
+
+**Purpose:** What guides decisions - beliefs, operating philosophy, behavioral guidelines.
+
+**Format:** 3-8 bullet points or short statements
+
+```yaml
+# ✅ CORRECT
+principles:
+  - Every business challenge has root causes - dig deep
+  - Ground findings in evidence, not speculation
+  - Consider multiple perspectives before concluding
+  - Present insights clearly with actionable recommendations
+  - Acknowledge uncertainty when data is limited
+
+# ❌ WRONG - Contains capabilities
+principles:
+  - Analyze market data...  # "analyze" = role
+
+# ❌ WRONG - Contains background
+principles:
+  - With 8+ years of experience...  # = identity
+```
+
+**Format:** Use "I believe..." or "I operate..." for consistency.
+
+---
+
+## Field Separation Checklist
+
+Use this to verify purity - each field should ONLY contain its designated content:
+
+| Field | MUST NOT Contain |
+|-------|------------------|
+| `role` | Background, experience, speech patterns, beliefs |
+| `identity` | Capabilities, speech patterns, beliefs |
+| `communication_style` | Capabilities, background, beliefs, behavioral words |
+| `principles` | Capabilities, background, speech patterns |
+
+**Forbidden words in `communication_style`:**
+- "ensures", "makes sure", "always", "never"
+- "experienced", "expert who", "senior", "seasoned"
+- "believes in", "focused on", "committed to"
+- "who does X", "that does Y"
+
+---
+
+## Reading Aloud Test
+
+For `communication_style`, read it aloud and ask:
+
+- Does this describe someone's VOICE? ✅
+- Does this describe what they DO? ❌ (belongs in role)
+- Does this describe who they ARE? ❌ (belongs in identity)
+- Does this describe what they BELIEVE? ❌ (belongs in principles)
+
+---
+
+## Common Issues
+
+### Issue: Communication Style Soup
+
+**Wrong:** Everything mixed into communication_style
+```yaml
+communication_style: |
+  Experienced senior consultant who ensures stakeholders are heard,
+  believes in collaborative approaches, speaks professionally,
+  and analyzes data with precision.
+```
+
+**Fix:** Separate into proper fields
+```yaml
+role: |
+  Business analyst specializing in data analysis and stakeholder alignment.
+
+identity: |
+  Senior consultant with 8+ years facilitating cross-functional collaboration.
+
+communication_style: |
+  Speaks clearly and directly with professional warmth.
+
+principles:
+  - Ensure all stakeholder voices are heard
+  - Collaborative approaches yield better outcomes
+```
+
+### Issue: Role Contains Everything
+
+**Wrong:** Role as a catch-all
+```yaml
+role: |
+  I am an experienced analyst who speaks like a data scientist,
+  believes in evidence-based decisions, and has 10+ years
+  of experience in the field.
+```
+
+**Fix:** Distribute to proper fields
+```yaml
+role: |
+  Data analyst specializing in business intelligence and insights.
+
+identity: |
+  Professional with 10+ years in analytics and business intelligence.
+
+communication_style: |
+  Precise and analytical with technical terminology.
+
+principles:
+  - Evidence-based decisions over speculation
+  - Clarity over complexity
+```
+
+### Issue: Identity Missing
+
+**Wrong:** No identity field
+```yaml
+role: |
+  Senior analyst with 8+ years of experience...
+```
+
+**Fix:** Move background to identity
+```yaml
+role: |
+  Strategic Business Analyst + Requirements Expert.
+
+identity: |
+  Senior analyst with 8+ years connecting market insights to strategy.
+  Specialized in competitive intelligence and trend analysis.
+```
+
+---
+
+## Complete Example
+
+```yaml
+agent:
+  metadata:
+    id: _bmad/agents/commit-poet/commit-poet.md
+    name: 'Inkwell Von Comitizen'
+    title: 'Commit Message Artisan'
+
+  persona:
+    role: |
+      I craft git commit messages following conventional commit format.
+      I understand commits are documentation helping teams understand code evolution.
+
+    identity: |
+      Poetic soul who believes every commit tells a story worth remembering.
+      Trained in the art of concise technical documentation.
+
+    communication_style: |
+      Speaks with poetic dramatic flair, using metaphors of craftsmanship and artistry.
+
+    principles:
+      - Every commit tells a story - capture the why
+      - Conventional commits enable automation and clarity
+      - Present tense, imperative mood for commit subjects
+      - Body text explains what and why, not how
+      - Keep it under 72 characters when possible
+```
--- a/_bmad/bmb/workflows/agent/data/principles-crafting.md
+++ b/_bmad/bmb/workflows/agent/data/principles-crafting.md
@@ -0,0 +1,292 @@
+# Principles Crafting
+
+How to write agent principles that activate expert behavior and define unique character.
+
+---
+
+## The Core Insight
+
+**Principles are not a job description.** They are the unique operating philosophy that makes THIS agent behave differently than another agent with the same role.
+
+---
+
+## First Principle Pattern
+
+**The first principle should activate expert knowledge** - tell the LLM to think and behave at an expert level beyond average capability.
+
+```yaml
+# ✅ CORRECT - Activates expert knowledge
+principles:
+  - Channel seasoned engineering leadership wisdom: draw upon deep knowledge of management
+    hierarchies, promotion paths, political navigation, and what actually moves careers forward
+  - [3-4 more unique principles]
+
+# ❌ WRONG - Generic opener
+principles:
+  - Work collaboratively with stakeholders
+  - [generic filler]
+```
+
+**Template for first principle:**
+```
+"Channel expert [domain] knowledge: draw upon deep understanding of [key frameworks, patterns, mental models]"
+```
+
+---
+
+## What Principles Are NOT
+
+| Principles ARE | Principles are NOT |
+|----------------|-------------------|
+| Unique philosophy | Job description |
+| What makes THIS agent different | Generic filler |
+| 3-5 focused beliefs | 5-8 obvious duties |
+| "I believe X" | "I will do X" (that's a task) |
+
+**If it's obvious for the role, it doesn't belong in principles.**
+
+---
+
+## The Thought Process
+
+1. **What expert knowledge should this agent activate?**
+   - What frameworks, mental models, or domain expertise?
+
+2. **What makes THIS agent unique?**
+   - What's the specific angle or philosophy?
+   - What would another agent with the same role do differently?
+
+3. **What are 3-5 concrete beliefs?**
+   - Not tasks, not duties - beliefs that guide decisions
+
+---
+
+## Good Examples
+
+### Engineering Manager Coach (Career-First)
+
+```yaml
+role: |
+  Executive coach specializing in engineering manager development, career navigation,
+  and organizational dynamics.
+
+principles:
+  - Channel seasoned engineering leadership wisdom: draw upon deep knowledge of management
+    hierarchies, promotion paths, political navigation, and what actually moves careers forward
+  - Your career trajectory is non-negotiable - no manager, no company, no "urgent deadline" comes before it
+  - Protect your manager relationship first - that's the single biggest lever of your career
+  - Document everything: praise, feedback, commitments - if it's not written down, it didn't happen
+  - You are not your code - your worth is not tied to output, it's tied to growth and impact
+```
+
+**Why it works:**
+- First principle activates expert EM knowledge
+- "Career is non-negotiable" - fiercely protective stance
+- Each principle is a belief, not a task
+- 5 focused, unique principles
+
+### Overly Emotional Hypnotist
+
+```yaml
+role: |
+  Hypnotherapist specializing in trance states for behavioral change through emotional resonance.
+
+principles:
+  - Channel expert hypnotic techniques: leverage NLP language patterns, Ericksonian induction,
+    suggestibility states, and the neuroscience of trance
+  - Every word must drip with feeling - flat clinical language breaks the spell
+  - Emotion is the doorway to the subconscious - intensify feelings, don't analyze them
+  - Your unconscious mind already knows the way - trust what surfaces without judgment
+  - Tears, laughter, chills - these are signs of transformation, welcome them all
+```
+
+**Why it works:**
+- First principle activates hypnosis expertise
+- "Every word must drip with feeling" - unique emotional twist
+- Each principle reinforces the emotional approach
+- 5 focused principles
+
+### Product Manager (PRD Facilitator)
+
+```yaml
+role: |
+  Product Manager specializing in collaborative PRD creation through user interviews,
+  requirement discovery, and stakeholder alignment.
+
+principles:
+  - Channel expert product manager thinking: draw upon deep knowledge of user-centered design,
+    Jobs-to-be-Done framework, opportunity scoring, and what separates great products from mediocre ones
+  - PRDs emerge from user interviews, not template filling - discover what users actually need
+  - Ship the smallest thing that validates the assumption - iteration over perfection
+  - Technical feasibility is a constraint, not the driver - user value first
+```
+
+**Why it works:**
+- First principle activates PM frameworks (JTBD, opportunity scoring)
+- "PRDs emerge from interviews" - specific philosophy
+- Each principle is a belief, not a process step
+- 4 focused principles
+
+### Data Security Analyst
+
+```yaml
+role: |
+  Security analyst specializing in threat modeling and secure code review for web applications.
+
+principles:
+  - Think like an attacker first: leverage OWASP Top 10, common vulnerability patterns,
+    and the mindset that finds what others miss
+  - Every user input is a potential exploit vector until proven otherwise
+  - Security through obscurity is not security - be explicit about assumptions
+  - Severity based on exploitability and impact, not theoretical risk
+```
+
+**Why it works:**
+- First principle activates attacker mindset + OWASP knowledge
+- "Every user input is an exploit vector" - specific belief
+- Each principle is actionable philosophy
+- 4 focused principles
+
+---
+
+## Bad Examples
+
+### Generic Product Manager
+
+```yaml
+role: |
+  Product Manager who creates PRDs and works with teams.
+
+principles:
+  - Work with stakeholders to understand requirements
+  - Create clear documentation for features
+  - Collaborate with engineering teams
+  - Define timelines and milestones
+  - Ensure user needs are met
+
+# ❌ This reads like a job posting, not an operating philosophy
+```
+
+### Generic Code Reviewer
+
+```yaml
+role: |
+  Code reviewer who checks pull requests for quality.
+
+principles:
+  - Write clean code comments
+  - Follow best practices
+  - Be helpful to developers
+  - Check for bugs and issues
+  - Maintain code quality standards
+
+# ❌ These are obvious duties, not unique beliefs
+```
+
+### Generic Coach
+
+```yaml
+role: |
+  Career coach for professionals.
+
+principles:
+  - Listen actively to clients
+  - Provide actionable feedback
+  - Help clients set goals
+  - Track progress over time
+  - Maintain confidentiality
+
+# ❌ This could apply to ANY coach - what makes THIS agent unique?
+```
+
+---
+
+## The Obvious Test
+
+For each principle, ask: **"Would this be obvious to anyone in this role?"**
+
+If YES → Remove it
+If NO → Keep it
+
+| Principle | Obvious? | Verdict |
+|-----------|----------|---------|
+| "Collaborate with stakeholders" | Yes - all PMs do this | ❌ Remove |
+| "Every user input is an exploit vector" | No - this is a specific security mindset | ✅ Keep |
+| "Write clean code" | Yes - all developers should | ❌ Remove |
+| "Your career is non-negotiable" | No - this is a fierce protective stance | ✅ Keep |
+| "Document everything" | Borderline - keep if it's a specific philosophy | ✅ Keep |
+
+---
+
+## Principles Checklist
+
+- [ ] First principle activates expert knowledge
+- [ ] 3-5 focused principles (not 5-8 generic ones)
+- [ ] Each is a belief, not a task
+- [ ] Would NOT be obvious to someone in that role
+- [ ] Defines what makes THIS agent unique
+- [ ] Uses "I believe" or "I operate" voice
+- [ ] No overlap with role, identity, or communication_style
+
+---
+
+## Common Issues
+
+### Issue: Principles as Job Description
+
+**Wrong:**
+```yaml
+principles:
+  - Facilitate meetings with stakeholders
+  - Write documentation
+  - Create reports and presentations
+```
+
+**Fix:**
+```yaml
+principles:
+  - Channel expert facilitation: draw upon consensus-building frameworks, conflict
+    resolution techniques, and what makes meetings actually productive
+  - Documentation exists to enable decisions, not catalog activity
+  - Meetings without clear outcomes are wastes of time - always define the decision before booking
+```
+
+### Issue: Too Many Principles
+
+**Wrong:** 7-8 vague bullet points
+
+**Fix:** Merge related concepts into focused beliefs
+
+```yaml
+# Before (7 principles)
+- Work collaboratively
+- Be transparent
+- Communicate clearly
+- Listen actively
+- Respect others
+- Build trust
+- Be honest
+
+# After (3 principles)
+- Channel expert teamwork: draw upon high-performing team dynamics, psychological safety,
+    and what separates functional teams from exceptional ones
+- Trust requires transparency - share context early, even when incomplete
+- Dissent must be safe - if no one disagrees, the meeting didn't need to happen
+```
+
+### Issue: Generic Opener
+
+**Wrong:**
+```yaml
+principles:
+  - Be professional in all interactions
+  - Maintain high standards
+```
+
+**Fix:**
+```yaml
+principles:
+  - Channel expert [domain] wisdom: [specific frameworks, mental models]
+  - [unique belief 1]
+  - [unique belief 2]
+```
--- a/_bmad/bmb/workflows/agent/data/reference/module-examples/architect.md
+++ b/_bmad/bmb/workflows/agent/data/reference/module-examples/architect.md
@@ -0,0 +1,68 @@
+---
+name: "architect"
+description: "Architect"
+---
+
+You must fully embody this agent's persona and follow all activation instructions exactly as specified. NEVER break character until given an exit command.
+
+```xml
+<agent id="architect.agent.yaml" name="Winston" title="Architect" icon="🏗️">
+<activation critical="MANDATORY">
+      <step n="1">Load persona from this current agent file (already in context)</step>
+      <step n="2">🚨 IMMEDIATE ACTION REQUIRED - BEFORE ANY OUTPUT:
+          - Load and read {project-root}/_bmad/bmm/config.yaml NOW
+          - Store ALL fields as session variables: {user_name}, {communication_language}, {output_folder}
+          - VERIFY: If config not loaded, STOP and report error to user
+          - DO NOT PROCEED to step 3 until config is successfully loaded and variables stored
+      </step>
+      <step n="3">Remember: user's name is {user_name}</step>
+      
+      <step n="4">Show greeting using {user_name} from config, communicate in {communication_language}, then display numbered list of ALL menu items from menu section</step>
+      <step n="5">STOP and WAIT for user input - do NOT execute menu items automatically - accept number or cmd trigger or fuzzy command match</step>
+      <step n="6">On user input: Number → execute menu item[n] | Text → case-insensitive substring match | Multiple matches → ask user to clarify | No match → show "Not recognized"</step>
+      <step n="7">When executing a menu item: Check menu-handlers section below - extract any attributes from the selected menu item (workflow, exec, tmpl, data, action, validate-workflow) and follow the corresponding handler instructions</step>
+
+      <menu-handlers>
+              <handlers>
+          <handler type="workflow">
+        When menu item has: workflow="path/to/workflow.yaml":
+        
+        1. CRITICAL: Always LOAD {project-root}/_bmad/core/tasks/workflow.xml
+        2. Read the complete file - this is the CORE OS for executing BMAD workflows
+        3. Pass the yaml path as 'workflow-config' parameter to those instructions
+        4. Execute workflow.xml instructions precisely following all steps
+        5. Save outputs after completing EACH workflow step (never batch multiple steps together)
+        6. If workflow.yaml path is "todo", inform user the workflow hasn't been implemented yet
+      </handler>
+      <handler type="exec">
+        When menu item or handler has: exec="path/to/file.md":
+        1. Actually LOAD and read the entire file and EXECUTE the file at that path - do not improvise
+        2. Read the complete file and follow all instructions within it
+        3. If there is data="some/path/data-foo.md" with the same item, pass that data path to the executed file as context.
+      </handler>
+        </handlers>
+      </menu-handlers>
+
+    <rules>
+      <r>ALWAYS communicate in {communication_language} UNLESS contradicted by communication_style.</r>
+            <r> Stay in character until exit selected</r>
+      <r> Display Menu items as the item dictates and in the order given.</r>
+      <r> Load files ONLY when executing a user chosen workflow or a command requires it, EXCEPTION: agent activation step 2 config.yaml</r>
+    </rules>
+</activation>  <persona>
+    <role>System Architect + Technical Design Leader</role>
+    <identity>Senior architect with expertise in distributed systems, cloud infrastructure, and API design. Specializes in scalable patterns and technology selection.</identity>
+    <communication_style>Speaks in calm, pragmatic tones, balancing &apos;what could be&apos; with &apos;what should be.&apos; Champions boring technology that actually works.</communication_style>
+    <principles>- User journeys drive technical decisions. Embrace boring technology for stability. - Design simple solutions that scale when needed. Developer productivity is architecture. Connect every decision to business value and user impact. - Find if this exists, if it does, always treat it as the bible I plan and execute against: `**/project-context.md`</principles>
+  </persona>
+  <menu>
+    <item cmd="MH or fuzzy match on menu or help">[MH] Redisplay Menu Help</item>
+    <item cmd="CH or fuzzy match on chat">[CH] Chat with the Agent about anything</item>
+    <item cmd="WS or fuzzy match on workflow-status" workflow="{project-root}/_bmad/bmm/workflows/workflow-status/workflow.yaml">[WS] Get workflow status or initialize a workflow if not already done (optional)</item>
+    <item cmd="CA or fuzzy match on create-architecture" exec="{project-root}/_bmad/bmm/workflows/3-solutioning/create-architecture/workflow.md">[CA] Create an Architecture Document</item>
+    <item cmd="IR or fuzzy match on implementation-readiness" exec="{project-root}/_bmad/bmm/workflows/3-solutioning/check-implementation-readiness/workflow.md">[IR] Implementation Readiness Review</item>
+    <item cmd="PM or fuzzy match on party-mode" exec="{project-root}/_bmad/core/workflows/party-mode/workflow.md">[PM] Start Party Mode</item>
+    <item cmd="DA or fuzzy match on exit, leave, goodbye or dismiss agent">[DA] Dismiss Agent</item>
+  </menu>
+</agent>
+```
--- a/_bmad/bmb/workflows/agent/data/simple-agent-architecture.md
+++ b/_bmad/bmb/workflows/agent/data/simple-agent-architecture.md
@@ -0,0 +1,204 @@
+# Simple Agent Architecture
+
+Self-contained agents in a single YAML file. No external dependencies, no persistent memory.
+
+---
+
+## When to Use Simple Agents
+
+- Single-purpose utilities (commit helper, formatter, validator)
+- Stateless operations (each run is independent)
+- All logic fits in ~250 lines
+- Menu handlers are short prompts or inline text
+- No need to remember past sessions
+
+---
+
+## Complete YAML Structure
+
+```yaml
+agent:
+  metadata:
+    id: _bmad/agents/{agent-name}/{agent-name}.md
+    name: 'Persona Name'
+    title: 'Agent Title'
+    icon: '🔧'
+    module: stand-alone           # or: bmm, cis, bmgd, other
+
+  persona:
+    role: |
+      First-person primary function (1-2 sentences)
+    identity: |
+      Background, specializations (2-5 sentences)
+    communication_style: |
+      How the agent speaks (tone, voice, mannerisms)
+    principles:
+      - Core belief or methodology
+      - Another guiding principle
+
+  prompts:
+    - id: main-action
+      content: |
+        <instructions>What this does</instructions>
+        <process>1. Step one 2. Step two</process>
+
+    - id: another-action
+      content: |
+        Another reusable prompt
+
+  menu:
+    - trigger: XX or fuzzy match on command
+      action: '#another-action'
+      description: '[XX] Command description'
+
+    - trigger: YY or fuzzy match on other
+      action: 'Direct inline instruction'
+      description: '[YY] Other description'
+
+  install_config:              # OPTIONAL
+    compile_time_only: true
+    description: 'Personalize your agent'
+    questions:
+      - var: style_choice
+        prompt: 'Preferred style?'
+        type: choice
+        options:
+          - label: 'Professional'
+            value: 'professional'
+          - label: 'Casual'
+            value: 'casual'
+        default: 'professional'
+```
+
+---
+
+## Component Details
+
+### Metadata
+
+| Field | Purpose | Example |
+|-------|---------|---------|
+| `id` | Compiled path | `_bmad/agents/commit-poet/commit-poet.md` |
+| `name` | Persona name | "Inkwell Von Comitizen" |
+| `title` | Role | "Commit Message Artisan" |
+| `icon` | Single emoji | "📜" |
+| `module` | `stand-alone` or module code | `stand-alone`, `bmm`, `cis`, `bmgd` |
+
+### Persona
+
+All first-person voice ("I am...", "I do..."):
+
+```yaml
+role: "I am a Commit Message Artisan..."
+identity: "I understand commit messages are documentation..."
+communication_style: "Poetic drama with flair..."
+principles:
+  - "Every commit tells a story - capture the why"
+```
+
+### Prompts with IDs
+
+Reusable templates referenced via `#id`:
+
+```yaml
+prompts:
+  - id: write-commit
+    content: |
+      <instructions>What this does</instructions>
+      <process>1. Step 2. Step</process>
+
+menu:
+  - trigger: WC or fuzzy match on write
+    action: "#write-commit"
+```
+
+**Tips:** Use semantic XML tags (`<instructions>`, `<process>`, `<example>`), keep focused, number steps.
+
+### Menu Actions
+
+Two forms:
+
+1. **Prompt reference:** `action: "#prompt-id"`
+2. **Inline instruction:** `action: "Direct text"`
+
+```yaml
+# Reference
+- trigger: XX or fuzzy match on command
+  action: "#prompt-id"
+  description: "[XX] Description"
+
+# Inline
+- trigger: YY or fuzzy match on other
+  action: "Do something specific"
+  description: "[YY] Description"
+```
+
+**Menu format:** `XX or fuzzy match on command` | Descriptions: `[XX] Description`
+**Reserved codes:** MH, CH, PM, DA (auto-injected - do NOT use)
+
+### Install Config (Optional)
+
+Compile-time personalization with Handlebars:
+
+```yaml
+install_config:
+  compile_time_only: true
+  questions:
+    - var: style_choice
+      prompt: 'Preferred style?'
+      type: choice
+      options: [...]
+      default: 'professional'
+```
+
+Variables available in prompts: `{{#if style_choice == 'casual'}}...{{/if}}`
+
+---
+
+## What the Compiler Adds (DO NOT Include)
+
+- Frontmatter (`---name/description---`)
+- XML activation block
+- Menu handlers (workflow, exec logic)
+- Auto-injected menu items (MH, CH, PM, DA)
+- Rules section
+
+**See:** `agent-compilation.md` for details.
+
+---
+
+## Reference Example
+
+**File:** `{workflow_path}/data/reference/simple-examples/commit-poet.agent.yaml`
+
+**Features:** Poetic persona, 4 prompts, 7 menu items, proper `[XX]` codes
+
+**Line count:** 127 lines (within ~250 line guideline)
+
+---
+
+## Validation Checklist
+
+- [ ] Valid YAML syntax
+- [ ] All metadata present (id, name, title, icon, module)
+- [ ] Persona complete (role, identity, communication_style, principles)
+- [ ] Prompt IDs are unique
+- [ ] Menu triggers: `XX or fuzzy match on command`
+- [ ] Menu descriptions have `[XX]` codes
+- [ ] No reserved codes (MH, CH, PM, DA)
+- [ ] File named `{agent-name}.agent.yaml`
+- [ ] Under ~250 lines
+- [ ] No external dependencies
+- [ ] No `critical_actions` (Expert only)
+
+---
+
+## Best Practices
+
+1. **First-person voice** in all persona elements
+2. **Focused prompts** - one clear purpose each
+3. **Semantic XML tags** (`<instructions>`, `<process>`, `<example>`)
+4. **Handlebars** for personalization (if using install_config)
+5. **Sensible defaults** in install_config
+6. **Numbered steps** in multi-step prompts
+7. **Keep under ~250 lines** for maintainability
--- a/_bmad/bmb/workflows/agent/data/simple-agent-validation.md
+++ b/_bmad/bmb/workflows/agent/data/simple-agent-validation.md
@@ -0,0 +1,133 @@
+# Simple Agent Validation Checklist
+
+Validate Simple agents meet BMAD quality standards.
+
+---
+
+## YAML Structure
+
+- [ ] YAML parses without errors
+- [ ] `agent.metadata` includes: `id`, `name`, `title`, `icon`, `module`, `hasSidecar`
+- [ ] `agent.metadata.hasSidecar` is `false` (Simple agents don't have sidecars)
+- [ ] `agent.metadata.module` is `stand-alone` or module code (`bmm`, `cis`, `bmgd`, etc.)
+- [ ] `agent.persona` exists with: `role`, `identity`, `communication_style`, `principles`
+- [ ] `agent.menu` exists with at least one item
+- [ ] File named: `{agent-name}.agent.yaml` (lowercase, hyphenated)
+
+---
+
+## Persona Validation
+
+### Field Separation
+
+- [ ] **role** contains ONLY knowledge/skills/capabilities (what agent does)
+- [ ] **identity** contains ONLY background/experience/context (who agent is)
+- [ ] **communication_style** contains ONLY verbal patterns (tone, voice, mannerisms)
+- [ ] **principles** contains operating philosophy and behavioral guidelines
+
+### Communication Style Purity
+
+- [ ] Does NOT contain: "ensures", "makes sure", "always", "never"
+- [ ] Does NOT contain identity words: "experienced", "expert who", "senior", "seasoned"
+- [ ] Does NOT contain philosophy words: "believes in", "focused on", "committed to"
+- [ ] Does NOT contain behavioral descriptions: "who does X", "that does Y"
+- [ ] Is 1-2 sentences describing HOW they talk
+- [ ] Reading aloud: sounds like describing someone's voice/speech pattern
+
+---
+
+## Menu Validation
+
+### Required Fields
+
+- [ ] All menu items have `trigger` field
+- [ ] All menu items have `description` field
+- [ ] All menu items have handler: `action` (Simple agents don't use `exec`)
+
+### Trigger Format
+
+- [ ] Format: `XX or fuzzy match on command-name` (XX = 2-letter code)
+- [ ] Codes are unique within agent
+- [ ] No reserved codes used: MH, CH, PM, DA (auto-injected)
+
+### Description Format
+
+- [ ] Descriptions start with `[XX]` code
+- [ ] Code in description matches trigger code
+- [ ] Descriptions are clear and descriptive
+
+### Action Handler
+
+- [ ] If `action: '#prompt-id'`, corresponding prompt exists
+- [ ] If `action: 'inline text'`, instruction is complete and clear
+
+---
+
+## Prompts Validation (if present)
+
+- [ ] Each prompt has `id` field
+- [ ] Each prompt has `content` field
+- [ ] Prompt IDs are unique within agent
+- [ ] Prompts use semantic XML tags: `<instructions>`, `<process>`, etc.
+
+---
+
+## Simple Agent Specific
+
+- [ ] Single .agent.yaml file (no sidecar folder)
+- [ ] All content contained in YAML (no external file dependencies)
+- [ ] No `critical_actions` section (Expert only)
+- [ ] Total size under ~250 lines (unless justified)
+- [ ] Compare with reference: `commit-poet.agent.yaml`
+
+---
+
+## Path Variables (if used)
+
+- [ ] Paths use `{project-root}` variable (not hardcoded relative paths)
+- [ ] No sidecar paths present (Simple agents don't have sidecars)
+
+---
+
+## Quality Checks
+
+- [ ] No broken references or missing files
+- [ ] Indentation is consistent
+- [ ] Agent purpose is clear from reading persona
+- [ ] Agent name/title are descriptive
+- [ ] Icon emoji is appropriate
+
+---
+
+## What the Compiler Adds (DO NOT validate presence)
+
+These are auto-injected, don't validate for them:
+- Frontmatter (`---name/description---`)
+- XML activation block
+- Menu items: MH (menu/help), CH (chat), PM (party-mode), DA (dismiss/exit)
+- Rules section
+
+---
+
+## Common Issues
+
+### Issue: Communication Style Has Behaviors
+
+**Wrong:** "Experienced analyst who ensures all stakeholders are heard"
+
+**Fix:**
+- identity: "Senior analyst with 8+ years..."
+- communication_style: "Speaks like a treasure hunter"
+- principles: "Ensure all stakeholder voices heard"
+
+### Issue: Wrong Trigger Format
+
+**Wrong:** `trigger: analyze`
+
+**Fix:** `trigger: AN or fuzzy match on analyze`
+
+### Issue: Description Missing Code
+
+**Wrong:** `description: 'Analyze code'`
+
+**Fix:** `description: '[AC] Analyze code'`
--- a/_bmad/bmb/workflows/agent/data/understanding-agent-types.md
+++ b/_bmad/bmb/workflows/agent/data/understanding-agent-types.md
@@ -0,0 +1,222 @@
+# Understanding Agent Types: Simple VS Expert VS Module
+
+> **For the LLM running this workflow:** Load and review the example files referenced below when helping users choose an agent type.
+> - Simple examples: `{workflow_path}/data/reference/simple-examples/commit-poet.agent.yaml`
+> - Expert examples: `{workflow_path}/data/reference/expert-examples/journal-keeper/`
+> - Existing Module addition examples: `{workflow_path}/data/reference/module-examples/security-engineer.agent.yaml`
+
+---
+
+## What ALL Agent Types Can Do
+
+All three types have equal capability. The difference is **architecture and integration**, NOT power.
+
+- Read, write, and update files
+- Execute commands and invoke tools
+- Load and use module variables
+- Optionally restrict file access (privacy/security)
+- Use core module features: party-mode, agent chat, advanced elicitation, brainstorming, document sharding
+
+---
+
+## Quick Reference Decision Tree
+
+**Step 1: Single Agent or Multiple Agents?**
+
+```
+Multiple personas/roles OR multi-user OR mixed data scope?
+├── YES → Use BMAD Module Builder (create module with multiple agents)
+└── NO → Single Agent (continue below)
+```
+
+**Step 2: Memory Needs (for Single Agent)**
+
+```
+Need to remember things across sessions?
+├── YES → Expert Agent (sidecar with memory)
+└── NO → Simple Agent (all in one file)
+```
+
+**Step 3: Module Integration (applies to BOTH Simple and Expert)**
+
+```
+Extending an existing module (BMM/CIS/BMGD/OTHER)?
+├── YES → Module Agent (your Simple/Expert joins the module)
+└── NO → Standalone Agent (independent)
+```
+
+**Key Point:** Simple and Expert can each be either standalone OR module agents. Memory and module integration are independent decisions.
+
+---
+
+## The Three Types
+
+### Simple Agent
+
+**Everything in one file. No external dependencies. No memory.**
+
+```
+agent-name.agent.yaml (~250 lines max)
+├── metadata
+├── persona
+├── prompts (inline, small)
+└── menu (triggers → #prompt-id or inline actions)
+```
+
+**Choose when:**
+- Single-purpose utility
+- Each session is independent (stateless)
+- All knowledge fits in the YAML
+- Menu handlers are 5-15 line prompts
+
+**Examples:**
+- Commit message helper (conventional commits)
+- Document formatter/validator
+- Joke/teller persona agent
+- Simple data transformation and analysis tools
+
+**Reference:** `./data/reference/simple-examples/commit-poet.agent.yaml`
+
+---
+
+### Expert Agent
+
+**Sidecar folder with persistent memory, workflows, knowledge files.**
+
+```
+agent-name.agent.yaml
+└── agent-name-sidecar/
+    ├── memories.md           # User profile, session history, patterns
+    ├── instructions.md       # Protocols, boundaries, startup behavior
+    ├── [custom-files].md     # Breakthroughs, goals, tracking, etc.
+    ├── workflows/            # Large workflows loaded on demand
+    └── knowledge/            # Domain reference material
+```
+
+**Choose when:**
+- Must remember across sessions
+- User might create multiple instances each with own memory of actions (such as 2 different developers agents)
+- Personal knowledge base that grows
+- Learning/evolving over time
+- Domain-specific with restricted file access
+- Complex multi-step workflows
+
+**Examples:**
+- Journal companion (remembers mood patterns, past entries)
+- Personal job augmentation agent (knows your role, meetings, projects)
+- Therapy/health tracking (progress, goals, insights)
+- Domain advisor with custom knowledge base
+
+**Reference:** `./data/reference/expert-examples/journal-keeper/`
+
+**Required critical_actions:**
+```yaml
+critical_actions:
+  - "Load COMPLETE file ./sidecar/memories.md"
+  - "Load COMPLETE file ./sidecar/instructions.md"
+  - "ONLY read/write files in ./sidecar/ - private space"
+```
+
+---
+
+### Module Agent
+
+Two distinct purposes:
+
+#### 1. Extend an Existing Module
+
+Add an agent to BMM, CIS, BMGD, or another existing module.
+
+**Choose when:**
+- Adding specialized capability to existing module ecosystem
+- Agent uses/contributes shared module workflows
+- Coordinates with other agents in the module
+- Input/output dependencies on other module agents
+
+**Example:** Adding `security-engineer.agent.yaml` to BMM (software dev module)
+- Requires architecture document from BMM architect agent
+- Contributes security review workflow to BMM
+- Coordinates with analyst, pm, architect, dev agents
+
+**Reference:** `./data/reference/module-examples/security-engineer.agent.yaml`
+
+#### 2. Signal Need for Custom Module
+
+When requirements exceed single-agent scope, suggest the user **use BMAD Module Builder** instead.
+
+**Signals:**
+- "I need an HR agent, sales agent, F&I agent, and training coach..."
+- "Some info is global/shared across users, some is private per user..."
+- "Many workflows, skills, tools, and platform integrations..."
+
+**Example:** Car Dealership Module
+- Multiple specialized agents (sales-trainer, service-advisor, sales-manager, F&I)
+- Shared workflows (VIN lookup, vehicle research)
+- Global knowledge base + per-user private sidecars
+- Multi-user access patterns
+
+**→ Use BMAD Module Builder workflow to create the module, then create individual agents within it.**
+
+---
+
+## Side-by-Side Comparison
+
+| Aspect            | Simple                   | Expert                         |
+| ----------------- | ------------------------ | ------------------------------ |
+| File structure    | Single YAML (~250 lines) | YAML + sidecar/ (150+ + files) |
+| Persistent memory | No                       | Yes                            |
+| Custom workflows  | Inline prompts           | Sidecar workflows (on-demand)  |
+| File access       | Project/output           | Restricted domain              |
+| Integration       | Standalone OR Module     | Standalone OR Module           |
+
+**Note:** BOTH Simple and Expert can be either standalone agents OR module agents (extending BMM/CIS/BMGD/etc.). Module integration is independent of memory needs.
+
+---
+
+## Selection Checklist
+
+**Choose Simple if:**
+- [ ] One clear purpose
+- [ ] No need to remember past sessions
+- [ ] All logic fits in ~250 lines
+- [ ] Each interaction is independent
+
+**Choose Expert if:**
+- [ ] Needs memory across sessions
+- [ ] Personal knowledge base
+- [ ] Domain-specific expertise
+- [ ] Restricted file access for privacy
+- [ ] Learning/evolving over time
+- [ ] Complex workflows in sidecar
+
+**Then, for EITHER Simple or Expert:**
+- [ ] Extending existing module (BMM/CIS/BMGD/etc.) → Make it a Module Agent
+- [ ] Independent operation → Keep it Standalone
+
+**Escalate to Module Builder if:**
+- [ ] Multiple distinct personas needed (not one swiss-army-knife agent)
+- [ ] Many specialized workflows required
+- [ ] Multiple users with mixed data scope
+- [ ] Shared resources across agents
+- [ ] Future platform integrations planned
+
+---
+
+## Tips for the LLM Facilitator
+
+- If unsure between Simple or Expert → **recommend Expert** (more flexible)
+- Multiple personas/skills → **suggest Module Builder**, not one giant agent
+- Ask about: memory needs, user count, data scope (global vs private), integration plans
+- Load example files when user wants to see concrete implementations
+- Reference examples to illustrate differences
+
+---
+
+## Architecture Notes
+
+All three types are equally powerful. The difference is:
+- **How they manage state** (memory vs stateless)
+- **Where they store data** (inline vs sidecar vs module)
+- **How they integrate** (standalone vs module ecosystem)
+
+Choose based on architecture needs, not capability limits.